Fi Collar Review: Is the Fi GPS Dog Collar Worth it?
After in-depth reviews and comparisons, we found that Tractive performs better and costs much less!
Fi is a well-known GPS collar brand, but it comes with a high price tag. With so many strong competitors on the market, is Fi Collar still worth buying? I thoroughly tested and compared Fi Collar with its strongest rival, Europe’s popular Tractive Collar. My review will give you the answer!
Tractive vs. Fi: Detailed Comparison
The purpose of purchasing a GPS collar is to prevent the loss of our loved ones. In view of the fact that these pets are actively moving, only real-time tracking can ensure they are being properly monitored. My test shows that only Tractive truly delivers on that promise, while fi collar often experience delays.
Lost Dog Mode – Tractive Has Faster Tracking
Tractive was quicker to track in my opinion. Lost Dog Mode went into effect quicker than Fi. The Fi delays a minute at a time when putting it in lost dog mode. This is huge when trying to locate your dog. My dog can cover some ground in a minute. The Tractive stays tracking the whole time. You can literally see your dog take a turn, run backwards..etc. You can also click on AR and it points you in the direction to head with an estimation of feet.
Here is how I tested this: I let my husband take both dogs without a phone on him. He tooks some hiking trails while I waited behind. Then, I placed both devices in lost mode. I did these three different days, at different times, in different places.
Connectivity – Tractive Notifies Me Faster
When I had one dog in Fi and the other in Tractive, Tractive always updated me first. I take multiple walks with my dogs each day. During those walks, I would leave my phone at home. Then I would look at the times of the notifications when I returned. Tractive won every day in different places.
Actually tracking the dog when lost – Tractive is real time
Once Tractive pulls up, it’s real time. Fi updates each minute.
Tractive won the PCMag Editor's Choice Award, and my test results matched the findings of PCMag experts, who wrote:
In testing, Tractive reliably sent a notification to my phone when Bradley exited and entered a Safe Zone. The tracker typically took about one minute to deliver an alert in those cases; that's at least a full minute faster than the Fi GPS collor, which usually took anywhere from two to three minutes to send an escape alert in testing. The Whistle was the slowest in our tests, taking around four-and-a-half minutes to send a notification, which as many pet owners know, is plenty of time for a determined doggo to ditch you.
By Angela Moscaritolo on PCMag
Tractive Has More Satisfied Customers
Another crucial issue to highlight is that both Fi occasionally encounters location errors during the tracking process, and the ‘Live mode' may take longer than expected. There are numerous complaints about these problems on Trustpilot, along with poor after-sales support. This has resulted in a very low rating of just 1.6 on the platform.
In contrast, Tractive boasts excellent firmware optimization, resulting in minimal occurrences of such issues. Combined with prompt and effective customer service, it maintains high customer satisfaction. On Trustpilot, over 90% of users have given ratings of 4 stars or above, highlighting its outstanding performance.
The Tractive Collar is an exceptional choice for a GPS collar, depending on the size of your pet dog, you can choose the model that suits you:
Tractive DOG 4
- Fits dogs as small as 4 kg;
- Up to 10 days without charging;
- More details
Tractive DOG XL / Adventure
- For all dogs above 22 kg;
- Up to 1 month without charging;
- More details
Reminder: Tractive is running a Limited-Time Fall Promotion where you can Save up to 30%, if you are interested, don’t miss this chance! (Visit Tractive's Promo Page>>)
Try risk-free: 30-day Money-Back Guarantee
Tractive Collar Monitors your Pet's health and activity
Health & Activity
Tractive tracker monitors your pet’s sleep and activity. With the help of AI, it can detect unusual patterns and send you an alert.
Designed for comfort.
Built for safety.
Tiny but tough
At 1.2 oz, it's as light as a couple of coins. And it fits dogs as small as 8.8 lbs. Great for Westies, and Great Danes too. Built to handle everything from daily walks to big adventures.
100% adventure and waterproof
Whether your dog loves to swim or likes to play rough, this waterproof tracker can take it.
Long-lasting battery
Go up to 10 days without charging. Recharge in under 2 hours. Boost battery life at home by setting up a Power Saving Zone. Exact time will vary based on coverage, usage and activity.
Try Risk-Free: 30-Day Money-Back Guarantee
Tractive is so confident in its product that it offers a 30-day money-back guarantee, which is rare among competitors. You can buy and try with complete peace of mind, risk-free!
Affordable price – You Can save a lot of money
The lifespan of a pet dog can be as long as fifteen years. If the annual subscription fee is very expensive, it will add up to be a big expense. I compared the price of Fi collar and Tractive Collar. Regardless of the subscription period, Tractive has the cheaper subscription price. This is especially true if you subscribe immediately to a five-year subscription. The monthly subscription price will only cost $5.
| Collar Price | Subscription fee: | |
| Fi Series 3 | N/A | 1 year: 192$ 2 years: 336$ (168$ per Year) |
| Tractive | 34.99$ (Get 30% Off from this link) | 1 year: 96$ 2 years: 144$ (72$ per Year) 5 Years: 300$ (60$ per Year) |
Another advantage is that you can cancel your subscription at any time. However, I do not recommend it. Because once the GPS collar can’t connect to the internet, you will only be able to rely on Bluetooth to obtain data. The tracking range for Bluetooth is extremely limited, so if your dog were to wander a bit further away, you would not be able to obtain GPS positioning data on your mobile phone. This will also affect your ability to locate your dog. During this time, there will be no point in having a dog collar. Tractive provides detailed information about the benefits of its subscriptions and the cancellation policy it offers: https://tractive.com/en/c/plans
For those considering the Tractive GPS collar, it is available on Amazon and the Tractive official site. However, I highly advise that you purchase directly from their official website. This ensures the creation of an account that is already integrated with their dedicated app and guarantees your access to their customer support team.
What Tractive's Cilient Say?
Cilient Review on Trustpilot
Cilient Review on Reddit
Cilient Review on Reddit
Tractive – Definitely worth a try
At $34.99, the Tractive GPS Dog LTE Tracker is one of the most affordable and best-performing pet trackers we've tested. It clips onto your pet's existing collar, accurately tracks their whereabouts at all times, quickly notifies you if they escape your Virtual Fence, and keeps tabs on their activity, sleep, and calories burned.
Compared to Fi Collar, Tractive offers a more affordable price, better performance, and higher customer satisfaction—making it definitely worth trying.
And with their 30-day money-back guarantee, you can test it out completely risk-free.
Plus, Tractive is running a Limited-Time Fall Sale this week, with savings of up to 30%.
It’s the perfect time to give it a try!
Try risk-free: 30-day Money-Back Guarantee!